Peer Reviewer Process

We are committed to prompt evaluation and publication of fully accepted papers in Civilization Research: Journal of Islamic Studies. To maintain a high-quality publication, all submissions undergo a rigorous review process. Characteristics of the peer review process are as follows:

  • Simultaneous submissions of the same manuscript to different journals will not be tolerated.
  • Manuscript articles that submit by online to the Civilization Research: Journal of Islamic Studies will be checked by the editorial board regarding focus and scope, an article template and plagiarism (max similarity 20%).
  • The manuscript that qualifies the focus and scope of the Civilization Research: Journal of Islamic Studies will be continued to the review process by at least two suitably qualified experts with a double-blind review.
  • The reviewing process by reviewers is done for at least four until eight weeks.
  • Papers will be refereed by at least 2 experts as suggested by the editorial board.
  • In addition, Editors will have the option of seeking additional reviews when needed. Authors will be informed when Editors decide further review is required.
  • All publication decisions are made by the journal's Editors-in-Chief on the basis of the referees' reports. Authors of papers that are not accepted are notified promptly.
  • All submitted manuscripts are treated as confidential documents. We expect our Board of Reviewing Editors and reviewers to treat manuscripts as confidential material as well.
  • Editors and reviewers involved in the review process should disclose conflicts of interest resulting from direct competitive, collaborative, or other relationships with any of the authors, and remove oneself from cases in which such conflicts preclude an objective evaluation. Privileged information or ideas that are obtained through peer review must not be used for competitive gain.
  • Our peer review process is confidential and the identities of reviewers cannot be revealed.